THE SHOCK ABSORBER
Dave Moore, executive pastor at Hunter Bible Church, published a piece for the Australian edition of the Gospel Coalition: “Spouses, Please Stop Sitting Together.”
The internet did what the internet does. The title was eventually softened to “Spouses, Consider Where You Sit at Church”, presumably after the first wave of reaction, but by then, there was som controversy.
What made it land so hard? The seating question is small, almost trivially so. Yet something in it touched a nerve that a hundred more serious theological articles didn’t.
What the Debate Is Actually About
Strip away the outrage and the clickbait framing, and the article is really making a claim about identity. When you walk into church as a married couple, what is the primary thing you are? A spouse? A family unit? Or a brother and sister in Christ among a room full of brothers and sisters in Christ?
Moore’s argument is that the worship gathering isn’t primarily about your marriage. It’s about the body of Christ. And if you park the car, file in together, sit together, and file out again without meaningfully engaging with anyone else in the room, you may have honoured your marriage, but you’ve missed something important about what church is for.
Jesus and the Family
Jesus doesn’t abolish the family. The New Testament still upholds marriage, still calls children to honour their parents, still takes family relationships seriously. But Jesus does something interesting with the family. He relativizes it.
There’s a moment in the gospels where his mother and brothers come looking for him, wanting to take him home, concerned he’s gone too far. Jesus looks around and says: who are my mother and brothers? Those who do the will of God. Biology still matters. But it isn’t the primary thing.
Then there’s the harder saying: unless you hate your father and mother, brother and sister, you cannot follow me. It’s hyperbole; Jesus elsewhere tells us to love our enemies, so he can hardly mean literal hatred. The word is doing a comparative job: I need to come before all of that. Everything else is relativized by allegiance to me.
Paul picks this up in the way he writes. His constant use of brother and sister language in the letters isn’t just rhetorical warmth. Joseph Hellerman’s book When the Church Was a Family, which makes the historical case that in the ancient world, sibling relationships were the most significant social bond you had — more significant than marriage. In a conflict between helping your wife and helping your sister, the ancient expectation was that you helped your sister. So when Paul calls the church brothers and sisters, he’s not reaching for a cosy metaphor. He’s making a claim about hierarchy. The gospel reshapes who your most important people are.
That relationship with your wife or husband, for example, the one grounded in Jesus, is actually the more fundamental one. The marriage relationship sits inside it, not above it.
The Case for Sitting Together
Stephen McAlpine wrote a response piece with the opposite headline: “Spouses, Sit Together at Church.” Griffin Gulledge added another. Their argument isn’t simply sentimental. It’s strategic.
The Western world is not friendly to the nuclear family. Marriage is contested, family stability is declining, and Christians who hold a traditional theology of marriage and sexuality are increasingly swimming against the current. For many couples, church is the one place where their commitment to each other can be unself-consciously expressed. Sitting together is a small, visible act of honouring what they believe.
The right honouring of families is genuinely part of the Christian tradition, and nothing in the counter-argument should flatten that. The problem is when the strategy becomes totalising. When sitting together becomes sitting together and nothing else, when the family unit becomes so self-enclosed that the room full of brothers and sisters in Christ becomes backdrop rather than the point. That’s when a right honouring of one thing tips into a failure to honour another.
Why We Fight
Why does a seating article produce this level of heat?
The answer lies somewhere with cognitive dissonance. We encounter an idea that conflicts with something we already believe, and it creates distress. The easiest resolution is to dismiss the new idea entirely, file it under “that can’t be right” and move on. The harder resolution is to renegotiate, to let the new idea actually do its work, to come out the other side with a more nuanced position. That’s psychologically costly. It takes effort, and it requires the willingness to be wrong.
There’s also tribalism. If someone on you team says it, I’ll agree. If someone on the other team says it, you disagree on principle before I’ve even processed the argument. The team boundary does the thinking for you. It’s efficient. It’s also how you end up defending positions you haven’t examined.
Is Fear Sinful?
A lot of the heat in the spouses debate, and in online Christian controversy generally, looks like fear. Fear of being wrong. Fear of having to change a public position. Fear of the breakdown of things that matter. Which raises a sharper question: is fear itself sinful?
Fear, as a physiological and psychological response, probably isn’t sinful in itself. What you do with it is the question. Do you turn it into control: grasping for certainty, dismissing the data that threatens you, retreating to the safety of your tribe? Or do you turn it into prayer?
That’s the fork. One path leads to control. The other leads to dependence on God.
Jesus in the Garden of Gethsemane is the clearest example. He is distressed, He sweats drops of blood. He asks whether the cup can pass from him. And he doesn’t sin. Because he takes the distress to God rather than away from God. The fear, or something close to it, becomes the occasion for prayer rather than the occasion for grasping.
Peter on the water is the other side. He steps out in faith, keeps his eyes on Jesus, and walks. Then he notices the storm. The storm was already there, it hadn’t changed. But his attention shifts, and he starts to sink. Jesus pulls him up: why did you fear? The question isn’t why did you notice the storm. It’s why did you let it pull your eyes away.
Proverbs 3:5-6 names the alternative. Trust in the Lord with all your heart, and lean not on your own understanding. The leaning-not-on-your-own-understanding part is what faith actually asks of you. It isn’t irrational, it’s recognising that God knows more than you do. A student who doesn’t yet understand what their teacher is explaining would be foolish to dismiss it rather than ask more questions and trust that the teacher has good reasons. How much more so with God.
The flaming arrows in Ephesians 6 are going to come. The question isn’t whether fear will show up. It’s whether you pick up the shield of faith or let the arrows spread.
Discussed on this episode
Dave Moore - “Spouses, Consider Where You Sit at Church"
Listen to the full conversation on the Shock Absorber podcast.
The Shock Absorber is a podcast for church leaders doing church a little differently. Next episode: the tangibles of church project management. Subscribe so you don't miss it. Email Joel at joel@shockabsorber.com.au, and join the Shock Absorber Network at shockabsorber.com.au.
Soul Revival Church is an Anglican church in the Sutherland Shire and Ryde.